The Showman

A former Blackwood ringmaster who believes a good story is more valuable than an inconvenient truth.

Possible motive: Ownership of the restored carnival

The Historian

A respected scholar determined to separate fact from legend—and be remembered as the person who finally solved the Blackwood mystery.

Possible motive: Access to Evie Blackwood’s personal ledger

The Keeper of Traditions

A lifelong champion of the carnival’s songs, games, and traditions who believes the restored show should travel again.

Possible motive: Control over the carnival’s future

The Investor

A successful businessperson who risked a fortune believing the restored carnival would become Murder Creek’s next major attraction.

Possible motive: Protecting a failing investment

The Museum Director

The leader of a struggling museum who believes acquiring the Blackwood collection could save both the institution and their career.

Possible motive: Ownership of the Blackwood collection